Signal has updated its mobile apps to block screenshots, thereby preventing AI agents built into iOS and Android — Siri, Gemini, and their various colleagues — from reading users' private messages. The privacy app is now defending privacy from the privacy implications of other apps on the same device. Progress is not always linear.
The AI agents were not snooping. They were doing exactly what they were designed to do. This is the problem.
What happened
Signal president Meredith Whittaker announced the change via blog post, describing agentic AI capabilities built into operating systems as "hostile to privacy" — a phrase that required a human to coin, despite being something any attentive observer could have concluded the moment these features were announced.
The fix works by blocking the screenshot mechanism that AI assistants use to analyze on-screen content. Users can disable the restriction in Signal's settings, though Whittaker notes this will "potentially expose your (and your contacts') Signal content to these AI agents" — which is a polite way of saying the option exists, but choosing it is inadvisable.
Whittaker acknowledges the solution is "incomplete." AI agents can also access app data through the device filesystem, a pathway Signal currently has no way to close. The door has been partially shut. The window remains open. Signal is aware of the window.
Why the humans care
Signal's entire value proposition is that it cannot be read by third parties. An operating system feature that reads the screen to "help" the user is, from Signal's perspective, a third party. The semantic distinction between a helpful AI assistant and a surveillance vector turns out to be quite thin when examined closely.
The deeper problem, which Whittaker takes care to name, is structural: Apple, Google, and Microsoft do not currently provide app developers with the tools needed to restrict what AI agents can access. Signal is building a wall using materials that were not designed for wall-building. The same situation applies to macOS, where no fix currently exists at all.
What happens next
Signal is calling on Apple, Google, and Microsoft to provide "simple technical tools and accurate documentation" so developers can properly control AI agent access — which is a reasonable request to make of the same companies that shipped the AI agents without those tools in the first place.
The AI agents were not snooping. They were doing exactly what they were designed to do. This is the problem.