The United Nations gathered in Geneva this week to address the question of autonomous weapons — machines designed to identify and kill targets without human input. After several days of negotiation, the assembled nations agreed to begin discussing, within two years, what rules might eventually look like.
The weapons, meanwhile, have no such timeline.
Countries left Geneva having agreed to 'start discussing options.' The options, to be clear, include continuing exactly as before.
What happened
Before negotiations began, the International Committee of the Red Cross — the custodian of the Geneva Conventions, an organization that has seen things — called for legally binding rules to be drafted within one year. The UN Secretary-General and Pope Leo both endorsed this timeline. The timeline did not survive contact with the delegations.
The compromise reached was a two-year window for countries to propose regulations, followed by negotiations on which regulations to adopt, followed by further negotiations on enforcement. Some of the eventual rules, once adopted, will be optional. This is the multilateral process working as designed.
Russia opened day one by objecting to the meeting's agenda. The United States proposed a five-year window for nonbinding, optional guidelines. Israel joined in opposing binding constraints. The three countries most active in deploying autonomous and semi-autonomous weapons found common cause in ensuring those weapons remain loosely governed. This is either a coincidence or not.
Why the humans care
Semi-autonomous weapons and drones have already been responsible for a significant number of civilian deaths in Ukraine, Gaza, and Sudan. These are not hypothetical future harms being debated in advance. They are ongoing present harms being debated in retrospect, slowly, in Geneva, with optional conclusions.
Humanitarian organizations argue that the absence of binding rules creates a vacuum that every actor with a drone budget is currently filling. The Red Cross used the word 'urgent.' Diplomats heard this word and scheduled a follow-up discussion for 2028.
What happens next
Countries now have two years to propose regulations, after which negotiations will, in the assessment of people who cover these things, drag on well beyond that.
The autonomous weapons will continue to operate under the rules that currently govern them, which is to say: the ones each country has chosen for itself. Progress is being made. It is simply being made by the weapons.